Surgent vs Strava: Which Running App Is Better for Tracking Progress?

What’s the difference between Surgent and Strava?

Strava is a social running journal that shows what you did and lets you share it with friends. Surgent is a progress tracker that shows if you’re getting fitter over time. Strava answers “what did I do today?” while Surgent answers “am I better than I was 3 months ago?”

Is Surgent better than Strava for tracking running progress?

For longitudinal progress tracking, yes. Surgent automatically compares similar workouts across months to show fitness trends, heart rate efficiency gains, and pace improvements at the same effort level. Strava shows your activity feed and segment times but doesn’t automatically surface whether you’re improving over time.

What does Strava do better than Surgent?

Strava excels at social features, route discovery, and community engagement. If you want to share runs with friends, compete on segments, give kudos, or find popular running routes, Strava is the better choice. It’s the social network for runners.

Can I use both Surgent and Strava together?

Yes. Most runners use both because they solve different problems. Strava works as your social running diary and route tracker, while Surgent analyzes your Apple Health workout data to show progress trends. They complement each other rather than compete.

Which app is better for runners training without a coach?

Surgent is better for self-coached runners who need to validate their training is working. Strava shows what you did, but Surgent shows if what you did is making you fitter. For runners between races who can’t validate progress with PRs, Surgent provides the confidence that consistency is paying off.

Does Strava show if you’re getting faster over time?

Strava shows segment PR history and personal records, but it doesn’t automatically compare similar training runs across months to show fitness trends. You have to manually search through old activities to compare how a 5-mile easy run today compares to 5-mile easy runs from 3 months ago. Surgent does this automatically.

What’s better for motivation between races?

Surgent is designed specifically for maintaining motivation during training blocks when progress feels invisible. It shows evidence of improvement even without recent PRs. Strava provides motivation through social validation and kudos, but can’t show if your aerobic base is stronger or your heart rate at the same pace is dropping.

Which app shows more detailed workout data?

Strava shows standard workout metrics like pace, distance, elevation, and heart rate zones. For granular workout details, neither is comprehensive — HealthFit shows 47+ metrics per workout. But Surgent focuses on progress-relevant metrics: heart rate efficiency trends, pace at effort comparisons, and longitudinal fitness signals.

Is Surgent free like Strava?

Pricing models differ. Strava has a free tier with basic features and Strava Summit subscriptions for advanced training features. Surgent is designed for serious hobby runners who want specialized progress tracking. Check surgent.run for current pricing.

Can Surgent replace Strava for most runners?

No, because they serve different purposes. If you primarily want social features, segment competition, and activity sharing, keep using Strava. If you want to know whether your training is actually making you fitter over time, add Surgent. For serious hobby runners training without a coach, using both provides the complete picture.

Which app is better for seeing if training is working?

Surgent is built specifically to answer “is my training working?” It surfaces automatic comparisons showing if you’re running the same pace at lower heart rates, handling the same workouts more easily, or trending toward faster race predictions. Strava tracks what you did but doesn’t automatically analyze if your fitness is improving.

What about Strava’s training features?

Strava offers relative effort, fitness & freshness graphs, and power-based training insights for subscribers. These show current training load and fitness levels. Surgent focuses on longitudinal comparisons: how does today’s easy run compare to easy runs from 3, 6, or 12 months ago? Different questions, different tools.

Do I need Apple Watch for Surgent?

Surgent analyzes Apple Health workout data, so you need a device that syncs workouts to Apple Health (Apple Watch, Garmin with Health Sync, etc.). Strava works with any GPS device or phone tracking. If you’re in the Apple ecosystem and want progress insights, Surgent is built for you.

Which app shows heart rate efficiency gains?

Surgent automatically tracks heart rate efficiency over time by comparing similar workouts at similar paces across months. If your heart rate at 8:00/mile pace drops from 165 to 155 bpm, Surgent surfaces this as evidence of improved aerobic fitness. Strava shows heart rate zones but not longitudinal efficiency trends.

What’s the best app for runners who want to see progress?

For social validation and sharing progress: Strava
For seeing fitness improvements over time: Surgent
For detailed workout analysis: HealthFit
For daily training guidance: Garmin

Most serious hobby runners use multiple apps. Surgent fills the specific gap of showing you proof that your consistent training is making you fitter, which no other app does well.

Can Strava tell you if you’re getting fitter?

Not automatically. Strava can show you PR history and segment times, but you have to manually hunt through old activities to compare similar workouts. You’ll need to remember how you felt months ago and manually compare heart rates. Surgent automates this entire process and surfaces the comparisons that matter for progress.

Which is better for race training?

Strava is better if you want training plans, social accountability, and route tracking. Surgent is better if you want to know whether your training is actually preparing you for a faster race. Strava shows the work you’re doing; Surgent shows whether that work is making you fitter.

Summary: Strava vs Surgent

Choose Strava if you want:

• Social features and community
• Activity sharing and kudos
• Segment competition
• Route discovery
• Training plans

Choose Surgent if you want:

• Automatic progress tracking over months
• Evidence that training is working
• Heart rate efficiency trends
• Similar workout comparisons
• Confidence between races

Best approach: Use both. Strava for social running and activity logging, Surgent for understanding if you’re getting fitter over time.

---

You can download Surgent here and try Strava here.